Can’t decide between DMARCReport and Valimail for managing your MTA-STS hosting and email authentication? You’re in the right place.
In this detailed comparison of DMARCReport vs Valimail, we’ll explore each platform’s core features, security benefits, pricing, and overall user experience—helping you choose the right solution to strengthen your domain’s email protection and deliverability.
Whether you’re a small business, SaaS startup, or enterprise with complex security needs, this guide will help you make an informed decision about the most effective MTA-STS hosting and DMARC reporting platform for your organization.
Why Email Authentication & MTA-STS Hosting Matter
Email authentication frameworks like DMARC, SPF, and DKIM, combined with MTA-STS hosting, protect your domain from phishing, spoofing, and man-in-the-middle attacks. With email still the top vector for cyber threats, adopting a robust authentication and reporting strategy is essential to ensure email integrity, deliverability, and trust.
Modern MTA-STS hosting platforms—like DMARCReport and Valimail—make implementing and managing these protocols seamless, even for teams without deep technical expertise.
DMARCReport vs Valimail: Key Feature Breakdown
| Feature | DMARCReport | Valimail |
| DMARC Reporting | ✅ Advanced forensic and aggregate reports | ✅ Standard DMARC reports |
| MTA-STS & TLS-RPT Hosting | ✅ Fully managed, auto-renewing SSL | ✅ MTA-STS configuration with limited automation |
| DNS Configuration Support | ✅ Hands-on setup & ongoing DNS health checks | ⚠️ Basic setup guidance |
| Multi-Domain Support | ✅ Unlimited domains, unified dashboard | 🚫 Limited on lower tiers |
| Integrations | ✅ API + SIEM integrations (Splunk, Microsoft 365, etc.) | ✅ Integrations via Valimail Align |
| Pricing Transparency | ✅ Simple, usage-based pricing | ⚠️ Custom quotes only |
| Reporting Frequency | ✅ Real-time dashboard + daily email summaries | ⚠️ Weekly summaries only |
| Support | ✅ Priority support with SLA | ✅ Standard email support |
DMARCReport: Seamless, Secure, and Transparent
DMARCReport is a fully managed DMARC and MTA-STS hosting platform built for organizations that want deep visibility into email authentication without the complexity.
🔐 Core Features
- Advanced DMARC Reporting: Aggregate and forensic DMARC reports are presented in a clean, actionable dashboard. You can easily pinpoint unauthorized senders, identify misconfigurations, and monitor domain compliance.
- Managed MTA-STS Hosting: Automatically hosts and maintains your MTA-STS and TLS-RPT policies, with auto-renewing SSL certificates to ensure ongoing encryption compliance.
- Real-Time Alerts: Get notified instantly when authentication failures occur, helping your team act fast against spoofing attempts.
- DNS Health Monitoring: Continuous scanning ensures your SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records are valid and optimized for maximum deliverability.
💡 Ideal For
Organizations that value hands-on support, transparent pricing, and automation-first security management. Whether you’re securing one domain or hundreds, DMARCReport scales effortlessly.
Valimail: Enterprise-Grade Authentication with a Corporate Focus
Valimail is a well-known name in the email authentication space, offering enterprise DMARC solutions and MTA-STS hosting as part of its broader product suite.
🔐 Core Features
- DMARC Management: Visual DMARC reporting with alignment scoring, though less granular than DMARCReport’s forensic analytics.
- MTA-STS Hosting: Supports publishing and maintaining MTA-STS policies, though configuration requires more manual work.
- Policy Automation: Automates certain DNS updates and record enforcement for enterprise clients.
- Brand Protection: Valimail’s ecosystem extends beyond MTA-STS, including BIMI support and sender identity management.
💡 Ideal For
Large enterprises that need integration with existing identity and access infrastructure, and have the in-house resources to manage more complex setups.
DMARCReport vs Valimail: Feature-by-Feature Comparison
1. MTA-STS Hosting
DMARCReport offers a fully automated MTA-STS hosting service, including SSL certificate management and TLS-RPT hosting—making it a true set-and-forget solution.
Valimail, by contrast, provides MTA-STS setup capabilities but with limited automation, requiring more manual updates.
2. Reporting & Analytics
DMARCReport excels with real-time dashboards and forensic-level insight into sending sources and authentication errors. Valimail offers detailed summaries, but at less frequent intervals and with fewer filtering options.
3. Integration Capabilities
Both platforms integrate with Microsoft 365, Google Workspace, and common security ecosystems. However, DMARCReport provides open API and SIEM integration, making it better suited for SOC or compliance teams that need data visibility across tools.
4. Customization & User Control
DMARCReport allows full visibility into policy enforcement (none → quarantine → reject) with custom thresholds and per-domain settings. Valimail’s configuration options are more rigid, emphasizing standardized compliance over flexibility.
Pricing Comparison: Transparent vs Enterprise
DMARCReport – Predictable and Scalable
- Free Tier: Includes basic DMARC monitoring and MTA-STS setup for one domain.
- Professional Plan: Adds multi-domain support, DNS health alerts, and advanced reporting.
- Enterprise Plan: Includes managed onboarding, SIEM integration, and dedicated security advisor.
✅ Simple monthly pricing, no hidden fees.
Valimail – Custom Quotes for Enterprises
Valimail’s pricing is tailored for large organizations. It includes enterprise support and additional features such as BIMI configuration, but details are not publicly listed.
⚠️ Expect higher starting costs and longer onboarding cycles.
User Experience & Support
DMARCReport: Clean, Transparent, and Actionable
DMARCReport’s interface is built for clarity, with a unified dashboard summarizing authentication status, DMARC alignment, and MTA-STS health across all domains.
The guided onboarding wizard helps even non-technical users deploy email security correctly from day one.
Valimail: Powerful but Complex
Valimail’s interface offers strong reporting but assumes technical familiarity. It’s ideal for teams with dedicated IT or security staff who can navigate advanced configurations.
Integrations & Automation
| Platform | Key Integrations | Automation Level |
| DMARCReport | Microsoft 365, Google Workspace, Splunk, AWS SES | 🔁 High – fully automated policy management |
| Valimail | Salesforce, Exchange, Proofpoint, Okta | ⚙️ Moderate – requires user verification steps |
Alternatives to DMARCReport and Valimail
If you’re exploring additional MTA-STS hosting or DMARC monitoring options, here are some alternatives to consider:
- Postmark: Focused on deliverability monitoring and SMTP analytics for transactional senders.
- PowerDMARC: A full suite for DMARC enforcement with a strong focus on domain forensics.
- EasyDMARC: Known for simplified dashboards and quick onboarding, ideal for small businesses.
- Dmarcian: Veteran platform offering compliance insights and educational resources for DMARC deployment.
Each alternative has its strengths, but DMARCReport stands out for combining ease of use, automation, and transparency—making it a top choice for businesses securing their email infrastructure without heavy IT overhead.
Final Verdict: DMARCReport vs Valimail — Which One Should You Choose?
Both platforms excel at enhancing domain trust and securing outbound email, but they cater to different audiences:
- Choose DMARCReport if you want automation, real-time analytics, transparent pricing, and responsive support. It’s perfect for small to medium organizations or MSPs managing multiple domains.
- Choose Valimail if you’re an enterprise looking for identity-centric integrations and are comfortable with more complex configurations and pricing models.
If you’re ready to take control of your email security stack, DMARCReport offers an intuitive, scalable solution for managing DMARC, MTA-STS, and TLS-RPT all in one place—so your brand’s domain reputation stays fully protected.
