Can’t decide between DMARCReport, EasyDMARC, or Valimail for DMARC reporting, email authentication, or MTA-STS hosting?
This comprehensive comparison breaks down the features, pricing, reporting depth, and user experience of each platform — helping you choose the best solution for securing your domain from spoofing, phishing, and unauthorized senders.

Whether you’re a growing startup or a large enterprise, this guide will help you evaluate which provider delivers the most reliable DMARC insights and domain protection.

Why DMARC, SPF, DKIM & MTA-STS Matter More Than Ever

Email remains the most exploited attack vector. DMARC, SPF, DKIM, MTA-STS, and TLS-RPT help organizations:

  • Stop spoofing and impersonation
  • Protect their domain reputation
  • Enforce secure email delivery
  • Gain visibility over sending sources
  • Prevent unauthorized senders from misusing their brand

DMARC visibility tools simplify complex XML reports into actionable insights — and MTA-STS/TLS-RPT hosting ensures encrypted mail transport and secure policy enforcement.

Let’s compare the three leading solutions

DMARCReport vs EasyDMARC vs Valimail: Key Features Breakdown

FeatureDMARCReportEasyDMARCValimail
DMARC Reporting✔ Advanced✔ Standard✔ Enterprise-Grade
SPF/DKIM Diagnostics✔ Deep✔ Standard✔ Enterprise
MTA-STS & TLS-RPT Hosting✔ Included✔ Add-on✔ Limited
User Experience✔ Streamlined✔ User-Friendly✔ Enterprise-Focused
Pricing✔ Cost-EffectiveModeratePremium

DMARCReport vs EasyDMARC vs Valimail: Feature-by-Feature Comparison

DMARCReport: Advanced Visibility, Fast Deployment, and Robust MTA-STS Hosting

DMARC Reporting & Aggregate Insights

DMARCReport excels with highly detailed DMARC report parsing, giving users deep visibility into:

  • Sending source identification
  • Pass/fail breakdowns
  • Authentication failures
  • Misconfigurations
  • Suspicious traffic surges

The platform focuses on clarity and accuracy, making it ideal for security teams and SMBs who need precise insights without clutter.

SPF, DKIM & DMARC Analysis

DMARCReport automatically checks:

  • SPF alignment issues
  • DKIM key problems
  • Record syntax
  • Authentication failures across providers

This is especially useful when onboarding new sending services or troubleshooting intermittent failures.

MTA-STS Hosting & TLS-RPT

DMARCReport includes secure and simple MTA-STS and TLS-RPT hosting, allowing organizations to enforce encrypted mail transfer with:

  • Fully hosted MTA-STS policy
  • Automatic HTTPS certificate management
  • TLS reporting dashboard

This positions DMARCReport as an all-in-one email authentication solution.

Integrations & Compatibility

DMARCReport integrates cleanly with:

Its flexible approach makes it ideal for hybrid or complex infrastructures.

Customization & Reporting

Users can configure:

  • Custom alerts
  • Sender grouping
  • Threat flags
  • Periodic summaries
  • Role-based access

This makes DMARCReport suitable for both technical and non-technical teams.

EasyDMARC: User-Friendly & Well-Rounded for SMBs

DMARC Management

EasyDMARC provides intuitive dashboards for DMARC compliance, helping teams quickly identify:

  • Misaligned senders
  • SPF/DKIM misconfigurations
  • Unauthorized traffic

Its visual approach is great for teams who want clarity without technical depth.

Security Add-Ons

EasyDMARC includes:

  • DNS change monitoring
  • BIMI guidance
  • SPF flattening
  • Email threat intelligence

These features make it a popular choice for SMBs looking for a guided onboarding process.

MTA-STS/TLS-RPT

EasyDMARC supports MTA-STS and TLS-RPT, but typically as an add-on.
The UI is simplified, but policy hosting is not as deep or granular as DMARCReport.

Integrations

EasyDMARC integrates with cloud email providers and standard DNS systems — great for small teams that want a simple setup.

Valimail: Enterprise-Grade Authentication & Automation

DMARC Enforcement

Valimail is built for large organizations needing strict authentication and automation at scale.
Its strengths include:

  • AI-driven sender identity
  • Automatic allowlisting
  • Enterprise reporting
  • Delegated authentication solutions

Valimail helps organizations reach p=reject with minimal manual work.

Authentication Automation

Valimail emphasizes full automation for:

  • SPF management
  • DKIM handling
  • Subdomain management
  • Permissive delegation

This reduces the workload for large IT departments that manage hundreds of senders.

MTA-STS Support

Valimail supports MTA-STS indirectly, but generally requires integration with separate products or enterprise setups — less turnkey than DMARCReport.

Integrations

Valimail integrates primarily with large enterprise ecosystems, identity platforms, and SIEM solutions.

Pricing Comparison

DMARCReport: Cost-Effective & Transparent

DMARCReport offers clear pricing that scales with domain and reporting needs:

  • Free tier available for testing
  • Affordable plans for SMBs
  • Advanced reporting at competitive rates
  • MTA-STS/TLS-RPT included at higher tiers

Ideal for teams needing robust reporting without enterprise-level pricing.

EasyDMARC: Mid-Range Pricing

EasyDMARC’s pricing is positioned for SMBs:

  • Free DMARC analyzer
  • Moderately priced plans for visibility and threat detection
  • Add-ons for SPF flattening, MTA-STS, and advanced security tools

Good value, but costs can add up with add-ons.

Valimail: Premium Enterprise Pricing

Valimail’s pricing is targeted at mid-size and large enterprises:

  • No meaningful free tier
  • Paid only
  • High cost for advanced automation
  • Pricing varies by organization size

Ideal only if you need automated, large-scale DMARC enforcement.

User Experience Comparison

DMARCReport: Clean, Fast & Highly Focused

DMARCReport provides:

  • Simple onboarding
  • Clear DMARC insights
  • Easy MTA-STS deployment
  • Minimal clutter
  • Helpful guided recommendations

Perfect for teams that want maximum insights with minimal complexity.

EasyDMARC: Visual & Beginner-Friendly

EasyDMARC offers:

  • Color-coded dashboards
  • Guided setup steps
  • Helpful tooltips
  • Easy sender identification

Great for users with limited technical background.

Valimail: Powerful for Enterprise, Complex for SMBs

Valimail’s interface is:

  • Feature-rich
  • Designed for enterprise workflows
  • Splendid for automation
  • More complex for small teams

Best suited for organizations with dedicated cybersecurity staff.

Integrations Overview

DMARCReport Integrations

  • Google Workspace
  • Microsoft 365
  • Cloudflare
  • Any DNS provider
  • SIEM systems via export
  • Custom MTAs

DMARCReport emphasizes compatibility and speed of deployment.

EasyDMARC Integrations

  • Google Workspace
  • Microsoft 365
  • DNS integrations
  • Email gateways
  • Built-in threat feeds

Best for smaller organizations needing simplicity.

Valimail Integrations

  • Enterprise clouds
  • Identity platforms
  • SIEM tools
  • Automated authentication systems

Best for large, complex infrastructures.

Why These Three Lead the Market

Each solution serves distinct needs:

DMARCReport

✔ Deep DMARC analytics
✔ Full MTA-STS/TLS-RPT hosting
✔ Clear onboarding
✔ Best balance of power & affordability

EasyDMARC

✔ Very user-friendly
✔ Helpful for SMBs
✔ Strong onboarding tools

Valimail

✔ Best for large enterprises
✔ Deep automation
✔ Advanced authentication management

Alternative Email Security Tools

If you’re exploring beyond DMARCReport, EasyDMARC, and Valimail, here are top additional options:

Postmark (Authentication-First Email Delivery)

Great for transactional email delivery with built-in authentication tools.

dmarcian (DMARC Education & Tools)

Strong educational resources and visual tooling.

Proofpoint (Enterprise Anti-Phishing)

Enterprise-class secure email gateway with DMARC enforcement support.

Cloudflare Email Security DNS Tools

Rapid DNS deployment and basic DMARC/SPF tools.

Final Verdict: DMARCReport vs EasyDMARC vs Valimail — Which Is Right for You?

DMARCReport is ideal if you want:

  • Deep, accurate DMARC reporting
  • Full MTA-STS/TLS-RPT hosting included
  • Fast setup and clean insights
  • A cost-effective alternative to enterprise tools

EasyDMARC is ideal if you want:

  • Simple setup
  • Clear visual dashboards
  • SMB-focused onboarding

Valimail is ideal if you want:

  • Enterprise-grade automation
  • AI-driven sender identification
  • Large-scale enforcement

For most businesses — SMB to mid-enterprise — DMARCReport provides the best combination of power, clarity, and affordability, especially with built-in MTA-STS hosting and highly detailed reporting.