Choosing between DMARCReport, EasyDMARC, and specialized MTA-STS hosting solutions can be challenging—especially for digital agencies managing multiple client domains, ensuring email deliverability, and maintaining airtight security standards.
This comprehensive comparison breaks down each solution’s features, pricing, integrations, and user experience to help digital agencies pick the best-fit email authentication partner. Whether you handle brand-sensitive clients or run high-volume outbound campaigns, this guide will help you choose the right DMARC and email authentication platform for your workflow.
Email authentication has become a non-negotiable pillar of modern digital operations. With rising spoofing, phishing, and BEC fraud, agencies must enforce protocols like DMARC, SPF, DKIM, MTA-STS, and TLS-RPT—not only to protect their clients’ domains but also to guarantee safe, high-deliverability email performance.
DMARCReport vs EasyDMARC vs MTA-STS Hosting: Key Feature Breakdown
| Platform | Core Strengths |
| DMARCReport | Robust reporting, multi-domain visibility, granular analytics, agency-focused tooling |
| EasyDMARC | Well-rounded DMARC suite, accessible UI, deliverability and security tools |
| MTA-STS Hosting Solutions | High-assurance transport-layer security, ideal for compliance-focused or high-risk clients |
DMARCReport vs EasyDMARC vs MTA-STS Hosting: Feature-by-Feature Comparison
DMARCReport: Purpose-Built Visibility & Automation for Agencies
DMARC & SPF/DKIM Monitoring
DMARCReport provides deep, multi-layered visibility into authentication results across all client domains. Agencies can instantly assess alignment failures, unauthorized senders, and deliverability threats through enriched analytics purpose-built for multi-domain environments.
Aggregate & Forensic Reporting
Its real-time dashboards transform raw XML DMARC data into digestible intelligence, helping teams identify vulnerabilities, rogue sending sources, and configuration gaps before attackers exploit them.
Client-Friendly Communication Tools
Digital agencies get branded reporting, easy-to-read visuals, and permission-based access—perfect for streamlining client communication without overwhelming them with technical noise.
Automation & Policy Migration
DMARCReport simplifies the process of moving from none → quarantine → reject, using guided recommendations and risk scoring to ensure that domains reach enforcement safely and quickly.
MTA-STS & TLS-RPT Support
DMARCReport includes diagnostics and monitoring for transport-layer security standards, ensuring encrypted email transit and providing TLS-RPT insights that agencies can use to document compliance.
EasyDMARC: User-Friendly All-In-One Email Authentication
DMARC, SPF, DKIM Tools
EasyDMARC offers a simplified interface for setting up and monitoring DMARC, SPF, and DKIM. It’s beginner-friendly and ideal for agencies needing accessible dashboards.
Deliverability Tools
Features such as SPF flattening, BIMI indicators, and email health checks help agencies keep client domains optimized and compliant with modern sending requirements.
Risk Management & Reporting
EasyDMARC provides threat mapping and actionable security alerts to help non-technical users identify and respond to authentication issues.
Integrations
It connects with common DNS providers, email platforms, and cloud systems, keeping onboarding light for small agencies or less-technical teams.
MTA-STS Hosting: High-Assurance Email Transport Security
What It Is
MTA-STS hosting services enforce encrypted email transit between sending and receiving servers. For digital agencies managing finance, healthcare, or enterprise clients, MTA-STS reduces the risk of downgrade attacks and TLS stripping.
Why Agencies Use It
- Essential for compliance-heavy industries
- Strengthens trust across email ecosystems
- Complements DMARC by securing the transport layer
- Works with TLS-RPT to report misconfigurations and upgrade paths
Who It’s Best For
Agencies supporting clients with strict security mandates or sensitive communications (legal, fintech, government, healthcare).
Pricing Breakdown: DMARCReport vs EasyDMARC vs MTA-STS Hosting
DMARCReport: Transparent, Scalable Agency Pricing
Free / Trial Options
DMARCReport typically offers trial-based onboarding so agencies can evaluate reporting depth and domain onboarding speed.
Standard & Growth Plans
Designed for teams managing numerous domains, these plans include:
- Bulk domain management
- Multi-client dashboards
- Enhanced DMARC analytics
- Priority support
Enterprise Plans
Larger agencies benefit from:
- Dedicated onboarding
- API integrations
- White-labeled reporting
- Advanced security monitoring including MTA-STS/TLS-RPT insights
EasyDMARC: Accessible Tiered Pricing
Basic Plan
Great for small agencies needing DMARC monitoring and easy dashboard-based insights.
Plus & Premium Plans
Adds deliverability optimization tools, BIMI utilities, and threat intelligence.
Enterprise
Custom pricing for agencies and large organizations managing dozens or hundreds of domains.
MTA-STS Hosting Services
Pricing varies by provider, but typically includes:
- Annual domain certification
- Policy hosting & renewal
- DNS configuration guidance
- TLS-RPT inbox and analytics
Agencies supporting many domains may benefit from bulk or umbrella security packages.
User Experience Comparison
DMARCReport: Built for High-Volume, High-Complexity Agency Workflows
Agencies praise DMARCReport’s clean reporting UX and the ability to pivot between dozens of client domains instantly. Its dashboards emphasize clarity without sacrificing technical detail.
EasyDMARC: Friendly UI for Beginners
EasyDMARC’s interface is intuitive, making it ideal for teams new to DMARC, SPF, or BIMI. Reports are simplified and easy to understand for clients without security backgrounds.
MTA-STS Hosting: Set-and-Forget Compliance
MTA-STS platforms typically require upfront configuration but minimal ongoing maintenance. Dashboards are usually more technical and focused purely on transport-layer security.
Integrations & Compatibility
DMARCReport Integrations
Works seamlessly with:
- Google Workspace
- Microsoft 365
- Major DNS providers
- SMTP and API-driven email systems
API access enables automation, client portal integration, and bulk domain operations.
EasyDMARC Integrations
Supports plug-and-play connections with cloud email platforms and DNS hosts—ideal for small teams.
MTA-STS Hosting Compatibility
Requires:
- DNS changes
- HTTPS policy hosting
- TLS-RPT inbox setup
Works with any domain registrar and DNS provider.
Why DMARCReport, EasyDMARC, and MTA-STS Hosting Stand Out
Digital agencies rely on email authentication tools for:
- Protecting clients from spoofing
- Preventing deliverability drops
- Staying compliant with evolving sending policies (Google, Yahoo, etc.)
- Managing multi-domain portfolios efficiently
Each option excels in different operational models:
- DMARCReport – Best for agencies needing deep visibility, multi-domain management, and automation
- EasyDMARC – Best for smaller or less technical teams needing simplicity
- MTA-STS Hosting – Best for clients needing bulletproof transport security and compliance
Top Alternatives for Email Authentication Tools
If you’re exploring beyond these three options, here are additional secure email authentication platforms suitable for digital agencies:
DMARCReport — The Agency-First Authentication Platform
DMARCReport remains the strongest choice for agencies due to:
- Multi-client management
- Clean actionable reporting
- MTA-STS/TLS-RPT monitoring
- Automated policy guidance
- Bulk domain operations
- White labeling for client presentations
ValiMail
Ideal for enterprise-level BIMI, DMARC enforcement, and strict compliance needs.
PowerDMARC
A strong security-focused suite with MFA, TLS monitoring, and advanced intelligence features.
Dmarcian
A trusted veteran solution with detailed documentation and robust DNS assessment tools.
Final Verdict: DMARCReport vs EasyDMARC vs MTA-STS Hosting — Which Should Digital Agencies Choose?
When selecting the right email authentication partner, consider your agency’s priorities:
- Choose DMARCReport if you want the best multi-domain visibility, agency-friendly reporting, granular analytics, and fast policy enforcement.
- Choose EasyDMARC if you prefer a beginner-friendly, easy-to-use platform for basic authentication and deliverability needs.
- Choose MTA-STS Hosting solutions if your clients require hardened, compliance-driven transport-layer security.
For most digital agencies, DMARCReport delivers the strongest balance of automation, usability, scalability, and reporting clarity—making it the top choice for high-volume domain portfolios and client-facing operations.
