Protecting client domains from spoofing, phishing, and deliverability issues has become a core responsibility for digital agencies. As more brands struggle with email security, authentication, and compliance pressures, agencies are increasingly expected to handle DMARC, SPF, DKIM, and now MTA-STS for their clients.

But not all authentication platforms are built for agencies.

If you’re comparing DMARCReport and Valimail—two of the industry’s most recognized solutions—you already know how crucial choosing the right platform is for your workflow, client experience, and the long-term scalability of your service offerings.

This in-depth guide breaks down:

DMARCReport vs Valimail feature differences
MTA-STS hosting capabilities
Reporting clarity and depth
Multi-client agency workflows
Pricing structures
User experience
Integrations
Best alternatives

Whether you’re a boutique email marketing agency managing a handful of domains or a large digital agency supporting dozens, this comparison will give you exactly what you need to determine the best platform.

💡 Authentication is no longer optional. With rising spoofing attacks and tighter spam filtering across inboxes, DMARC and MTA-STS are mission-critical for brand trust, deliverability, and compliance.

👉 DMARCReport is the #1 authentication and MTA-STS hosting solution optimized specifically for digital agencies and managed service teams.

DMARCReport vs Valimail: Feature Comparison Overview

Below is a high-level snapshot before we go deeper:

Category	DMARCReport	Valimail
DMARC Reporting	Agency-optimized, highly visual, per-domain segmentation	Strong, enterprise-oriented reporting
MTA-STS Hosting	Fully automated, zero-maintenance hosting	Available but not streamlined
SPF & DKIM Tools	Automated SPF flattening, alignment checks	Authentication automation tools
Agency Workflow Support	Built-in multi-tenant client dashboard	Possible, but not purpose-built
Pricing	Flexible and scalable for agencies	Enterprise pricing tiers

DMARCReport vs Valimail: Feature-by-Feature Deep Dive

DMARCReport: The Top Choice for Digital Agencies Managing Client Authentication

DMARCReport was designed from the ground up for digital agencies, email service consultants, and managed deliverability providers who oversee multiple client domains. It focuses on simplicity, automation, and actionable intelligence rather than complex enterprise overhead.

⭐ DMARC Reporting (RUA + RUF)

DMARCReport provides:

Detailed aggregate (RUA) and forensic (RUF) reports
Visual graphs and breakdowns by source, IP, provider, and pass/fail alignment
Automated detection of suspicious sources
Multi-client segmentation for agency workflows
Daily, weekly, and scheduled summaries
Threat pattern identification

It’s built so agency teams can quickly interpret data and show clients clear value.

⭐ Fully-Managed MTA-STS Hosting

Unlike most providers, DMARCReport handles:

Hosting the .well-known/mta-sts.txt file
Hosting the MTA-STS TLS policy
Certificate management
Monitoring misconfigurations
Auto-renewal and auto-updating

For agencies, this massively reduces operational overhead.

⭐ SPF & DKIM Automation Tools

DMARCReport offers:

Automated SPF flattening
DKIM alignment tests
DNS record evaluation tools
Alerts for misconfigurations
IP/domain source grouping
Automated recommendations

These help eliminate common causes of DMARC failure.

⭐ Multi-Client Agency Dashboard

This is where DMARCReport truly stands out.

All clients in one interface
Customizable reporting access
Per-client isolation
Project-level permissions
Role-based access for team members
White-label exportable reports

Perfect for agencies that interact directly with client stakeholders.

⭐ Integrations

DMARCReport integrates with:

ESPs (Mailgun, Postmark, SendGrid, Klaviyo)
Support systems (Zendesk, Intercom)
Slack alerts
SIEM tools
API for custom workflows

Who DMARCReport Is Best For:

Digital agencies
Email service providers
Managed service providers
Deliverability consultants
IT support agencies
Agencies managing 5–500 client domains

Valimail: Authentication Automation for Enterprise Environments

Valimail is a powerful email authentication automation platform, known for its enterprise features and alignment controls.

⭐ Authentication Automation

Valimail automates:

DMARC enforcement
SPF management
DKIM verification
Policy alignment

The platform is particularly strong for internal corporate teams with rigid security requirements.

⭐ Reporting Capabilities

Valimail includes:

Comprehensive DMARC dashboards
Organization-based insights
Traffic source mapping
Anomaly detection

Reporting is strong but less tailored for multi-client agency workflows.

⭐ MTA-STS Support

Valimail supports MTA-STS, though hosting and policy management require more manual input compared to DMARCReport’s fully managed system.

⭐ Enterprise Integrations

Valimail excels in integrations with:

Identity management systems
Enterprise security tools
Corporate compliance platforms

Who Valimail Is Best For:

Large corporations
Government organizations
Enterprises with complex identity systems
Internal security teams

Pricing Comparison: DMARCReport vs Valimail

Here’s the expanded breakdown adapted from the original structure:

DMARCReport Pricing: Transparent & Agency-Friendly

DMARCReport offers affordable and scalable pricing ideal for agencies with multiple client domains.

Starter Plan

Perfect for small agencies or early-stage client monitoring:

Basic DMARC reporting
DNS record monitoring
SPF & DKIM validation
Limited MTA-STS insights

Growth Plan

Adds serious firepower:

Multi-client workspace
Automated SPF flattening
DKIM alignment reports
Expanded DMARC analytics
Alerts & notifications
API access

Agency / Enterprise Plan

The most complete offering for teams supporting dozens or hundreds of domains:

Full MTA-STS hosting
White-label reporting
Team member and client permissions
High-volume RUA processing
Dedicated support & onboarding
SLA guarantees

Pricing is predictable and scales by domain count, not by user, making it cost-efficient for agencies.

Valimail Pricing: Enterprise-Tier Structure

Valimail divides offerings into:

Standard
Premium
Enterprise

Pricing usually requires consultation and is oriented toward enterprise-level domains, often making it expensive for agencies managing multiple clients.

User Experience: DMARCReport vs Valimail

DMARCReport: Clean, Accessible, Agency-Friendly UI

DMARCReport is designed for clarity:

Clean visual dashboards
Client-by-client organization
Easy domain setup
Fast onboarding
Minimal learning curve
Non-technical stakeholders can understand reports

Agencies praise DMARCReport for how quickly they can show value to clients.

Valimail: Powerful but Enterprise-Centric UX

Valimail offers:

Robust, detailed dashboards
Strict access controls
Deep technical settings

However, the platform assumes a corporate IT audience and may feel heavy for smaller agency teams.

Integrations & Compatibility

DMARCReport Integrations

Mailgun, Postmark, SendGrid
Slack alerts
Zendesk / Intercom
Custom webhooks
API access for automation

Valimail Integrations

Identity platforms
Large security ecosystems
Microsoft Exchange environments

Both platforms support DNS-based integrations universally.

Why DMARCReport and Valimail Are Market Leaders

DMARCReport leads in:

Agency workflows
Clear reporting
Multi-client management
Automated MTA-STS hosting
Pricing transparency

Valimail leads in:

Enterprise identity integration
Compliance toolsets
Authentication automation

Both platforms are highly capable—but their ideal users differ significantly.

Best Alternatives to DMARCReport and Valimail

Here are expanded versions of the alternatives section, adapted to your niche:

Mailhardener: Full Domain Protection Suite

Mailhardener bundles DMARC, DKIM, SPF, MTA-STS, and BIMI into a single environment. Best for organizations needing an all-in-one protective layer without agency features.

Postmark DMARC Digests

A simple, lightweight DMARC-only tool for small businesses. Weekly digests are useful but insufficient for agencies or high-risk clients.

Proofpoint Email Security

A large-scale enterprise email security platform. Strong, but extremely heavy for agencies needing simple reporting and MTA-STS hosting.

Google Postmaster Tools

Essential for Gmail deliverability, but limited to Gmail traffic and not a replacement for DMARC reporting.

Final Verdict: DMARCReport vs Valimail—Which Should Digital Agencies Choose?

If you’re a digital agency managing multiple client domains and you need:

Automated MTA-STS hosting
Multi-client dashboards
Clear, actionable DMARC reporting clients can understand
Affordable per-domain pricing
Simple onboarding and management

👉 Choose DMARCReport. It is purpose-built for you.

If you are an internal enterprise security team and you need:

Deep identity management integrations
Corporate-level authentication automation
Large-scale security infrastructure support

👉 Choose Valimail.

Both are excellent platforms, but for agencies running authentication services, MTA-STS hosting, and deliverability support,