Choosing the right provider for DMARC monitoring, MTA-STS hosting, TLS reporting, and end-to-end SaaS email authentication is critical. With email threats rising — including phishing, spoofing, TLS downgrade attacks, and compliance gaps — SaaS companies need a reliable, automated way to secure sending domains and protect customer trust.

In this DMARCReport vs Valimail vs Other Providers comparison, we break down everything that matters:

  • Feature-by-feature breakdown
  • MTA-STS hosting reliability
  • TLS reporting depth
  • Pricing and scalability
  • Ease of use
  • Integrations and automation
  • Real SaaS-specific distinctions
  • Best alternatives
  • Final verdict

Whether you operate a fast-moving SaaS startup or manage a multi-domain enterprise, this guide will help you choose the right email security partner to protect your domain reputation and ensure secure message delivery.

💡 DMARC, SPF, DKIM, MTA-STS, and TLS-RPT are now essential email authentication controls for SaaS companies—not only for deliverability but for brand protection, phishing defense, and compliance.

👉 DMARCReport includes free MTA-STS hosting + automated TLS reporting — ideal for SaaS teams.

DMARCReport vs Valimail vs Other Providers: Key Feature Breakdown

Understanding how each provider handles authentication, hosting, and automation is the key to choosing the right SaaS security solution.

ProviderDMARC MonitoringMTA-STS HostingTLS ReportingBIMI SupportAutomationIdeal For
DMARCReportAdvanced, granularFully hosted + automatedUnified + continuous✔HighSaaS, SMBs, distributed teams
ValimailEnterprise-gradeHosted w/ enterprise SLAsStrong✔MediumLarge enterprises
Other ProvidersBasic–moderateOften partial or manualLimitedVariesLowMixed/legacy tools

Feature-by-Feature Deep Dive

DMARCReport: Complete Email Authentication + Automated MTA-STS for SaaS Environments

DMARCReport is designed for modern SaaS teams, offering a clean dashboard, fully automated MTA-STS hosting, instant onboarding, and best-in-class visibility into email authentication systems.

1. DMARC Monitoring & Alignment Intelligence

DMARCReport’s visibility tools include:

  • Detailed aggregate (RUA) reports
  • Forensic (RUF) analysis for unauthorized usage
  • Source-based filtering
  • Machine-identified authentication patterns
  • Clear per-sender alignment breakdown

This makes it easy to identify misconfigurations and prevent spoofing before attackers leverage your brand.

2. Fully Hosted MTA-STS

MTA-STS prevents downgrade attacks and ensures email is delivered securely via encrypted TLS channels.

DMARCReport provides:

  • Fully automated policy hosting
  • Automatic HTTPS certificate management
  • Zero-maintenance renewal
  • Subdomain support
  • Integrity checks and uptime monitoring
  • Failure notifications and proactive alerts

This is one of the strongest hosted MTA-STS implementations available for SaaS platforms with multiple sending services.

3. Automated TLS Reporting (TLS-RPT)

TLS-RPT protects outbound email pathways by monitoring failed TLS handshakes, insecure routes, and downgrade attempts.

DMARCReport:

  • Collects all global TLS-RPT messages
  • Normalizes them into human-readable dashboards
  • Highlights trends and error patterns
  • Prioritizes threats and deliverability issues

SaaS companies using many transactional sending services (e.g., SendGrid, SES, Mailgun, Postmark) benefit significantly.

4. BIMI + Brand Protection

DMARCReport includes a BIMI preparation set, enabling SaaS brands to:

  • Validate logos
  • Ensure proper SVG formatting
  • Confirm DMARC p=quarantine or reject
  • Prepare for VMC issuance

5. Integrations

DMARCReport integrates seamlessly with:

  • Microsoft 365
  • Google Workspace
  • Cloudflare
  • Major email API services (SendGrid, SES, Mailgun, SparkPost)
  • Slack for notifications
  • SIEM tools (exports)
  • SOC2 & ISO27001 compliance dashboards (reports)

6. Customization + Multi-Domain Support

Perfect for SaaS teams managing many sub-brands, microservices, or client email identities.

Valimail: Enterprise-Focused Automation for Identity-Based Email Controls

Valimail has a strong reputation in the enterprise ecosystem and specializes in automating complex identity structures for globally distributed organizations.

1. DMARC Monitoring

Valimail’s dashboards map sending sources automatically and support deep investigation tools for compliance-heavy industries.

2. Hosted MTA-STS

Valimail provides hosted MTA-STS with enterprise SLAs and uptime guarantees. It is reliable and secure, though more expensive than alternatives.

3. Automation

Valimail automates:

  • SPF record management
  • DKIM onboarding
  • Sending-source validation

This is excellent for enterprises with dozens of vendors sending on their behalf.

4. Integrations

Strong support for:

  • SIEM platforms (Splunk, Sumo Logic, ELK)
  • Identity providers
  • Enterprise security tools

5. Who is Valimail best for?

  • Fortune 500 companies
  • Government agencies
  • Enterprises with formal ITIL processes

Other Providers: Limited MTA-STS and Basic Reporting

Other DMARC vendors or DNS hosting services often offer:

  • Limited or manual MTA-STS setup
  • No automated HTTPS certificate rotation
  • Incomplete TLS-RPT parsing
  • Outdated dashboards
  • Less SaaS-friendly pricing

These solutions may work for small static domains but not for SaaS platforms that rely on multiple cloud-based email senders.

Pricing Comparison: Which Platform Fits Your Budget?

DMARCReport: Transparent, Fair, SaaS-Friendly

  • Free Tier: Full hosted MTA-STS + TLS-RPT + DMARC monitoring
  • Pro Tier: Automated workflows, BIMI, threat analysis
  • Enterprise: SSO/SAML, SIEM integrations, SLAs

DMARCReport is the only provider offering free hosted MTA-STS with automated maintenance.

Valimail: Premium Enterprise Pricing

Valimail offers advanced features but is generally priced for:

  • Large organizations
  • Security teams with enterprise budgets
  • Complex identity environments

There’s usually no entry-level free hosted MTA-STS.

Other Providers: Varies Widely

Often:

  • Lower-cost tools
  • Minimal automation
  • No TLS-RPT normalization
  • Manual MTA-STS setup

User Experience + Onboarding

DMARCReport: Modern, Clean, SaaS-Optimized

  • Fast setup
  • DNS validation guides
  • Automated onboarding flows
  • Intuitive dashboards
  • Excellent for DevOps, IT, and SaaS product teams

Valimail: Rich but More Complex

  • Highly detailed
  • Better for enterprise security engineers
  • Greater learning curve

Other Providers

  • UI varies
  • Often outdated
  • Limited automation

Integrations: Ecosystem Compatibility

DMARCReport

  • SendGrid, SES, Mailgun, Postmark
  • M365, Google Workspace
  • Cloudflare
  • Slack
  • SIEM exports
  • Webhooks

Valimail

  • SIEM platforms
  • Enterprise identity systems
  • M365 and Google
  • Governance tools

Others

  • Minimal or no integrations
  • Often manual

Why DMARCReport and Valimail Lead the Market

Both platforms dominate because they offer:

  • End-to-end DMARC compliance
  • Hosted MTA-STS
  • TLS-RPT visibility
  • Email authentication automation
  • Brand protection tools
  • Multi-domain management

But the target users differ sharply:

DMARCReport

  • SaaS companies
  • Startups and SMBs
  • IT + DevOps teams that need simplicity and automation

Valimail

  • Large enterprises
  • Government and financial institutions
  • Organizations requiring identity-based authorization controls

Top Alternatives to DMARCReport and Valimail

1. PowerDMARC — Threat Intelligence + Enterprise Tools

Strong for MSPs and multinational corporations.

2. dmarcian — DMARC Pioneers with Visualization Focus

Good dashboards but limited MTA-STS support.

3. Agari (HelpSystems) — AI-Driven Email Threat Defense

Focused on brand hijacking and high-level threat detection.

4. Mimecast — SEG + Add-on DMARC

Broad security suite but not a specialized DMARC/MTA-STS host.

Final Verdict: DMARCReport vs Valimail — Which One Should SaaS Teams Choose?

Choose DMARCReport if you want:

✔ Free hosted MTA-STS hosting
✔ Automated TLS-RPT with normalized dashboards
✔ Fast onboarding
✔ SaaS-friendly UI
✔ Affordable pricing
✔ Strong multi-domain management
✔ No maintenance required

DMARCReport is the best choice for SaaS teams needing reliable, automated email authentication and transport security with minimal overhead.

Choose Valimail if you want:

✔ Enterprise-class identity automation
✔ Deep SIEM integrations
✔ Strict governance workflows
✔ Large-scale, complex email ecosystems

Valimail is best for enterprises with mature security programs.

Final Recommendation

For most SaaS companies, DMARCReport is the clear winner.

It offers:

  • The easiest setup
  • The best value
  • Automated MTA-STS hosting
  • Unified TLS reporting
  • A modern, developer-friendly interface
  • Zero maintenance for certificates and policies

If you need the most cost-efficient, scalable, and easy-to-manage email authentication platform — DMARCReport is the top choice.

If your organization is a large enterprise with heavy compliance and identity governance needs — Valimail may be a better fit.

Ready to Protect Your SaaS Domain?

Start today with DMARCReport and get:

  • Free hosted MTA-STS
  • Automated TLS reporting
  • Detailed DMARC visibility
  • Zero-touch maintenance
  • A platform built for SaaS teams

Your users, customers, and brand reputation will thank you.