Email authentication is no longer optional—especially for SaaS companies that rely on secure, trusted, and high-volume outbound email. If you’re evaluating EasyDMARC, Valimail, or DMARCReport for DMARC compliance, reporting, enforcement, and MTA-STS hosting, this comprehensive comparison will help you choose the right platform.

Whether you’re a fast-growing SaaS startup or an enterprise managing thousands of domains, this guide breaks down each provider’s features, pricing, integrations, and user experience—so you can confidently select the best solution for deliverability, security, and compliance.

💡 DMARC, SPF, DKIM, MTA-STS, and TLS reporting are essential for protecting SaaS email channels from spoofing, phishing, and unauthorized sending.
SaaS brands that ignore them risk deliverability issues, domain impersonation, customer trust loss, and compliance failures.

EasyDMARC vs Valimail vs DMARCReport: Quick Feature Overview

ProviderDMARC ReportingSPF/DKIM ToolsMTA-STS HostingTLS-RPTSaaS-Friendly APIsPricing
DMARCReport ✔ Enterprise-grade✔ Automated SPF optimization✔ Fully managed & instant deploy✔ Advanced✔ Modern, simpleBest value
EasyDMARC✔ Good✔ Some tools✖ Limited✔✔Mid-range
Valimail✔ Strong✔ Strict SPF mgmt✔ Available but complex✔ Enterprise✔ EnterpriseHighest

EasyDMARC vs Valimail vs DMARCReport: Feature-by-Feature

DMARCReport: The Simplest Path to SaaS Email Security

DMARCReport leads with clarity, automation, and speed, offering SaaS teams an intuitive interface, rapid onboarding, and fully managed MTA-STS, TLS-RPT, and DMARC enforcement workflows without complexity.

DMARC & Aggregate Reporting

DMARCReport provides highly visual dashboards and actionable insights that surface issues faster than raw XML parsing. SaaS teams can detect unauthorized senders, misconfigured providers, and deliverability failures instantly.

SPF, DKIM, & Alignment Automation

The platform includes automatic SPF flattening, record health checks, and DKIM alignment tools—ideal for SaaS companies using multiple ESPs like SendGrid, Mailgun, Amazon SES, Postmark, and HubSpot.

Fully Managed MTA-STS Hosting

This is where DMARCReport stands out.
Your brand offers:

  • Instant MTA-STS deployment
  • Automatic certificate monitoring
  • Zero maintenance TXT and policy hosting
  • Built-in TLS-RPT reporting for visibility

Most SaaS teams lack expertise in MTA-STS—DMARCReport solves this with one-click hosting and management.

Integrations & API Support

Modern webhooks and APIs simplify domain provisioning, DMARC data ingestion, and SOC/security stack workflows.

Why SaaS Teams Choose DMARCReport

  • Clean, modern UI
  • Fastest setup (minutes, not days)
  • Industry-leading MTA-STS hosting
  • Transparent pricing
  • Built for teams, not just email admins

EasyDMARC: A Balanced, User-Friendly Email Security Tool

EasyDMARC is known for its lightweight interface and straightforward DMARC reporting. It’s a good fit for smaller teams or organizations looking for easy onboarding.

DMARC Reporting

EasyDMARC offers digestible reports and good visualization, making it a beginner-friendly choice.

SPF/DKIM Tools

It includes basic SPF lookups and DKIM validation but lacks automated or advanced SPF flattening compared to DMARCReport.

MTA-STS & TLS Reporting

EasyDMARC provides basic TLS reporting but does not offer fully-managed MTA-STS hosting—SaaS teams must manage policy hosting and deployments themselves.

Integrations

Integrations are adequate but more limited compared to Valimail or DMARCReport.

Best For

  • Small businesses
  • Teams starting DMARC for the first time
  • Low-complexity email environments

Valimail: Enterprise-Grade Authentication with Higher Complexity

Valimail is a heavyweight platform offering strict policy controls and granular enterprise-level security. It is powerful but often more than a SaaS startup needs.

DMARC & Enforcement

Valimail excels in DMARC enforcement for large enterprises and government-level compliance environments.

SPF Management

Their automated SPF management is one of the strongest in the industry but comes with licensing and vendor lock-in considerations.

MTA-STS Support

Valimail supports MTA-STS but requires more complex configuration and is not “instant deploy” like DMARCReport’s workflow.

Integrations & APIs

Integrations are robust but built for enterprise security stacks, SIEM systems, and multi-department environments.

Best For

  • Large enterprises with security teams
  • Government or regulated industries
  • Complex, multi-domain infrastructures

Pricing Comparison: DMARCReport vs EasyDMARC vs Valimail

DMARCReport: Best Value for SaaS

Transparent, usage-based pricing with all core tools included:

  • DMARC reporting
  • SPF/DKIM validation
  • Fully managed MTA-STS & TLS-RPT
  • Unlimited sending sources
  • Team collaboration features

Best return on investment for SaaS teams needing scalability without enterprise-level overhead.

EasyDMARC: Mid-Range Pricing

Affordable for small-to-mid sized companies, with:

  • Good reporting
  • Optional add-ons
  • Basic MTA-STS support (no managed hosting)

Valimail: Premium Enterprise Pricing

Higher cost but includes advanced authentication controls and optional managed services—usually suited for large organizations requiring compliance-driven security.

User Experience & Interface Comparison

DMARCReport: Clean, Fast, and Built for SaaS

  • Minimal learning curve
  • Modern dashboards
  • Highly readable DMARC XML insights
  • One-click domain onboarding

EasyDMARC: Simple & Beginner-Friendly

  • Straightforward UI
  • Limited advanced controls

Valimail: Powerful but Complex

  • Designed for enterprise security teams
  • Steeper setup and operational learning curve

Integration Comparison

DMARCReport Integrations

  • Modern REST API
  • Webhooks
  • Simplified domain automation for SaaS platforms
  • Easy connections with ESPs and cloud providers

EasyDMARC Integrations

  • Basic API
  • Fewer automation tools

Valimail Integrations

  • Deep integrations for SIEM, enterprise security suites, and large providers
  • More powerful but also more complex

Alternative Email Authentication Solutions

If you’re exploring the DMARC ecosystem beyond the big three, here are noteworthy alternatives:

1. Postmark DMARC Tools

Great for teams already using Postmark for transactional email.

2. PowerDMARC

Strong feature set with a wide range of authentication tools.

3. Agari (Now part of Fortra)

Enterprise-level threat intelligence and authentication.

4. dmarcian

Trusted and long-established DMARC reporting platform.

Each tool caters to different technical needs—ranging from SMB-friendly dashboards to enterprise threat-intelligence suites.

Final Verdict: EasyDMARC vs Valimail vs DMARCReport — Which Is Best for SaaS?

Let’s break down the ideal match:

Choose DMARCReport if you want:

  • The most intuitive DMARC reporting
  • Fully managed MTA-STS hosting (huge advantage for SaaS)
  • Simple onboarding
  • Affordable pricing
  • Automation built for software teams

Choose EasyDMARC if you want:

  • Easy DMARC reports
  • A beginner-friendly tool
  • Low-complexity deployment

Choose Valimail if you want:

  • Enterprise-level authentication
  • Deep compliance and governance
  • High-security environments

Why DMARCReport Is the Best Choice for SaaS

DMARCReport provides the perfect balance of usability, security, and automation. For SaaS companies that send high-volume customer communications, onboarding emails, transactional notifications, and marketing campaigns, DMARCReport delivers:

  • Stronger security
  • Easier deployment
  • Managed MTA-STS hosting
  • Better value
  • Modern developer-friendly APIs

If you operate a SaaS platform, DMARCReport is the best all-around solution for protecting your domain, improving deliverability, and simplifying compliance.