Email authentication has gone from a “nice-to-have” to a non-negotiable layer of cybersecurity, especially for MSPs responsible for protecting client domains at scale. As phishing attacks, spoofing, and business email compromise (BEC) continue to rise, MSPs need DMARC monitoring platforms that not only provide visibility—but operationalize compliance, simplify enforcement, and integrate with their security stack.

In this in-depth guide, we compare EasyDMARC vs Valimail vs DMARCReport from the perspective of MSPs, MSSPs, and IT resellers tasked with managing dozens or hundreds of client domains. We explore everything from multi-tenant management and forensic reporting to pricing models, integrations, and overall ecosystem fit.

Whether you’re formalizing your email authentication offering or upgrading from spreadsheets and raw XML reports, this comparison will help you choose the platform that aligns best with your MSP’s workflows, margins, and scalability goals.

Why DMARC Monitoring Matters for MSPs More Than Ever

MSPs have become primary frontline defenders in email security. But DMARC itself is only part of the equation—what matters is operational visibility, sender intelligence, and ongoing monitoring.

A modern MSP-ready DMARC platform must provide:

✔ Multi-tenant client management

✔ Automated forensic + aggregate analysis

✔ Clear progress tracking toward enforcement

✔ White-label customer reporting

✔ Alerting and remediation workflows

✔ Integrations with PSA, SIEM, RMM, and SOC tools

✔ Scalable pricing that fits MSP service stacks

The difference between tools built for individual businesses and tools built for MSPs is massive. Our comparison highlights that distinction clearly.

EasyDMARC vs Valimail vs DMARCReport: Quick Overview

Platform	Ideal For	Strengths	Weaknesses
DMARCReport	MSPs & MSSPs	Multi-tenant, white-label, deep analytics, PSA/RMM integrations	Less known brand than legacy providers
EasyDMARC	SMBs, small MSPs	Simple interface, broad security toolkit	Limited multi-tenant MSP tooling
Valimail	Large enterprises	Automation, identity-based authentication	Enterprise pricing, steep learning curve for MSPs

Key Feature-by-Feature Showdown

1. DMARCReport: Built From the Ground Up for MSPs

DMARCReport is purpose-built for MSPs managing DMARC enforcement across many client domains. Every feature is designed to reduce technician overhead, improve client deliverability, and streamline reporting.

DMARC Monitoring & Analytics

DMARCReport offers:

Real-time DMARC aggregate (RUA) + forensic (RUF) reporting
Intelligent pattern detection
Automatic grouping of senders
Misaligned source flagging
DKIM/SPF alignment scoring
Enforcement tracking with milestones

The platform is designed to highlight issues before they become client-facing deliverability problems.

MSP Multi-Tenant Environment

This is where DMARCReport outperforms most competitors.

A single pane of glass for all clients
Unlimited domains
Separate client dashboards
Technician roles & permissions
Fully white-label UX and reports

MSPs can run DMARC as a profitable recurring service without juggling multiple accounts.

White-Label Reporting & Client Communication

DMARCReport includes:

Custom-branded weekly/monthly executive summaries
Client-friendly DMARC explanations
Automated domain health scoring
PDF exports and automated email delivery

This allows MSPs to show measurable security improvements to nontechnical clients.

SPF & DKIM Troubleshooting

DMARCReport automatically:

Detects SPF flattening issues
Highlights DKIM misalignments
Flags failing sources
Recommends corrective actions

This reduces time spent digging through DNS records and XML reports.

Integrations for MSP Workflows

DMARCReport connects with systems MSPs already rely on:

PSA: ConnectWise, Autotask, HaloPSA
RMM: NinjaOne, N-able, Atera
SIEM/SOC tools
Webhooks + full API
Ticket automation for new DMARC issues

This dramatically reduces manual work.

Customization & Automation

MSPs can define:

Alert thresholds
Auto-classification rules
Reporting cadence
Enforcement guidance templates
Client permissions

DMARCReport scales seamlessly with your MSP business model.

2. EasyDMARC: User-Friendly, Accessible & Security-Focused

EasyDMARC is a widely adopted platform known for simplicity and anapproachable interface. It’s ideal for small businesses and MSPs who only manage a few domains.

DMARC Reporting & Visualization

Clean, easy-to-read dashboards
Basic aggregate + forensic reporting
Sender classification
Domain health scoring

It’s ideal for teams just beginning to implement DMARC.

Additional Email Security Features

EasyDMARC includes:

BIMI generator & validator
SPF flattening service
Phishing simulation tools
DNS configuration recommendations

MSPs wanting a general-purpose toolkit may appreciate these add-ons.

Integrations

EasyDMARC provides:

API access
Slack/Teams notifications
Some SIEM integrations

Its integration depth is lighter than MSP-focused tools but sufficient for smaller environments.

Automation & Preset Workflows

SPF & DKIM setup assistants
Automated alerts
Simple enforcement guidance

Good for beginner MSPs or organizations without a dedicated security team.

3. Valimail: Enterprise-Grade Automation & Identity-Based Sender Management

Valimail is known for its enterprise sophistication and automated approach to email authentication.

Automated DMARC Enforcement

Valimail’s standout capability is:

Automated third-party discovery
Automated configuration recommendations
Identity-based authentication mapping

Enterprises with complex email ecosystems often choose Valimail for its automation depth.

AI-Driven Authentication Intelligence

Valimail uses AI to:

Classify senders
Detect anomalies
Prevent shadow IT services
Provide recommended DNS updates

This reduces the need for deep DMARC expertise—ideal for large orgs.

Enterprise Integrations

Valimail integrates with:

SSO/IdP platforms
Large-scale IAM suites
Enterprise security stacks
Leading cloud infrastructures

MSPs may find this excessive unless supporting large corporate clients.

Enterprise Limitations for MSPs

No true multi-tenant MSP dashboard
High pricing tier
Workflow complexity
Not optimized for large numbers of small clients

It’s a powerful solution—but not always the most MSP-friendly.

Pricing Comparison: Which Platform Delivers the Best Value?

DMARCReport Pricing (MSP-Friendly)

DMARCReport offers:

Volume-based per-domain pricing
Unlimited users & client accounts
White-labeling included
Full feature set without enterprise lock-ins

This makes it ideal for MSP recurring revenue bundles.

EasyDMARC Pricing

Affordable entry plans
Add-ons available a la carte
Simple per-domain pricing

Best for small MSPs or SMB IT teams.

Valimail Pricing

Enterprise-tier pricing
Custom quotes
Higher cost for DMARC enforcement automation

Best suited for large companies, not budget-conscious MSPs.

User Experience & Learning Curve Comparison

DMARCReport: MSP Workflow Optimized

Clean, modern UI
Designed for technicians and account managers
Streamlined escalation workflows
Clear step-by-step enforcement roadmap

Ideal for MSPs with distributed teams.

EasyDMARC: Friendly & Accessible

Very simple onboarding
Minimal learning curve
Great for nontechnical users

Excellent for basic email security deployments.

Valimail: Robust but Complex

Feature-rich dashboard
Requires orientation/training
Strong for enterprise security teams
Less suited for small-client handling

Best for organizations managing complex environments.

Integrations & Ecosystem Fit

DMARCReport Integrations

PSA (ConnectWise, Autotask, HaloPSA)
RMM (Atera, NinjaOne, N-able)
SIEM/SOC tools
Email security gateways
API + Webhooks
Automated ticket creation

A powerful fit for MSP service operations.

EasyDMARC Integrations

Email security tools
Slack/Teams
Basic API connectivity

Good but limited.

Valimail Integrations

Enterprise IAM
SSO/identity providers
Cloud infrastructure tools

Excellent for enterprises—not optimized for MSP workflows.

Advanced Capability Comparison

SPF Flattening & Optimization

DMARCReport: SPF diagnostics & DNS record optimization guidance
EasyDMARC: SPF flattening tool
Valimail: Intelligent SPF recommendations

BIMI Support

DMARCReport: BIMI reporting + validation
EasyDMARC: BIMI generator + setup assistance
Valimail: Enterprise BIMI services

Forensic (RUF) Reporting

DMARCReport: Full forensic analysis with filtering
EasyDMARC: Supported with limitations
Valimail: Supported, enterprise-focused

Threat & Anomaly Detection

DMARCReport: Sender anomaly analysis & alerts
EasyDMARC: Basic threat insights
Valimail: Identity-based anomaly detection

White-Labeling

DMARCReport: Full platform + reports
EasyDMARC: Some white-label options
Valimail: Enterprise-only custom branding

Alternatives Worth Considering

PowerDMARC

Advanced DMARC suite with SOC integrations.

dmarcian

Education-focused, long-standing vendor.

Agari

High-end threat intelligence & BEC defense.

OnDMARC

Strong domain analysis tools and enforcement guidance.

Final Verdict: Which DMARC Platform Should MSPs Choose?

Choose DMARCReport if you’re an MSP or MSSP that needs:

Multi-tenant domain management
Clear, automated client reporting
PSA/RMM integrations
Full white-label environment
Scalable, predictable pricing
Technician-friendly dashboards
Quick visibility across 100s of domains

DMARCReport is the most MSP-centric platform of the three.

Choose EasyDMARC if:

You want a simple set-and-go platform
Your MSP manages only a small number of domains
You need an all-in-one toolkit including BIMI and SPF flattening

A great fit for small and midsize organizations.

Choose Valimail if:

You support large enterprises
You need deep automation
Your clients have sprawling, complex email infrastructures

Excellent for corporate IT, less ideal for MSP stacks.

Bottom Line

If you’re an MSP focused on service delivery efficiency, recurring revenue, and scaling your email security offering, DMARCReport provides the most complete, cost-effective, MSP-first solution among the three.