Choosing the right email security provider is one of the most important decisions a digital agency can make—especially when your clients rely on you to protect their domains from spoofing, phishing, and deliverability failures. In this comprehensive comparison of EasyDMARC vs PowerDMARC vs DMARCReport, we break down each platform’s features, pricing, MTA-STS hosting capabilities, reporting depth, and ease of use.
Whether you’re an MSP, reseller, hosting provider, or a growth-focused digital agency, this guide will help you find the best DMARC & MTA-STS hosting solution for your clients.
Modern email authentication has become essential for all organizations—even small businesses. With DMARC enforcement now required by inbox providers like Google and Yahoo, agencies need turnkey solutions to:
- Host DMARC, SPF, DKIM, and MTA-STS/BIMI records
- Monitor authentication failures
- Prevent spoofing and phishing
- Resolve SPF alignment issues
- Deliver managed email security to clients efficiently
Let’s dive into the ultimate email authentication showdown.
EasyDMARC vs PowerDMARC vs DMARCReport: Key Feature Breakdown
DMARCReport
DMARCReport delivers a no-frills, highly reliable hosted DMARC & MTA-STS environment designed specifically for agencies managing multiple domains. With clean dashboards, instant DNS hosting, branded white-label reports, and unlimited aggregate data retention, DMARCReport focuses on transparency, clarity, and long-term security visibility for all client email domains.
EasyDMARC
EasyDMARC is known for its visually friendly dashboards and straightforward onboarding. Designed for SMBs and mid-market businesses, it packages DMARC monitoring, BIMI tools, and DNS record guidance into a unified interface.
PowerDMARC
PowerDMARC positions itself as a full enterprise-grade email authentication suite, offering advanced options like hosted DKIM keys, hosted MTA-STS, TLS-RPT, MSP portals, and S/MIME. It’s feature-dense and geared toward larger organizations seeking premium automation and layered security mechanisms.
Feature-by-Feature Comparison
DMARCReport: The Clear, Fast, Agency-Optimized Choice
DMARC & SPF Monitoring
DMARCReport provides precise SPF, DKIM, and DMARC data with:
- Granular per-source authentication analysis
- Tools for reducing SPF lookups
- Instant misconfiguration alerts
- Easy domain-by-domain overview for agencies
Perfect for agencies handling dozens—or hundreds—of client domains.
MTA-STS Hosting (Core Differentiator)
DMARCReport offers fully hosted MTA-STS with:
- Automated policy deployment
- Zero server maintenance
- Built-in TLS-RPT monitoring
- Ultra-fast global CDN delivery
Agencies get enterprise-grade MTA-STS for clients without managing HTTPS certificates or policy hosting.
Aggregate & Forensic Reporting
Clean, filterable reports designed for clarity:
- Unlimited retention
- Geo and IP-based threat breakdowns
- Automated white-label weekly/monthly client summaries
Integrations
DMARCReport integrates smoothly with agency workflows:
- API for pulling DMARC insights into client dashboards
- Webhooks for alerts
- Connectors for major mail service providers
Customization for Agencies
DMARCReport shines here, including:
- White-label portals
- Client access roles
- Bulk domain management
- Centralized status dashboard
EasyDMARC: Simple & Visual for Small–Mid Agencies
DMARC Setup & Monitoring
EasyDMARC supports guided DMARC onboarding with recommendations that helpSMBs quickly reach DMARC enforcement.
MTA-STS Hosting
Available, but less customizable than enterprise-focused providers. Designed more for small business deployment than multi-domain agency infrastructure.
BIMI & Security Tools
EasyDMARC includes BIMI record builders and phishing monitoring tools for clients who want brand protection beyond email authentication.
Integrations
Works well for basic integrations with platforms like:
- Office 365
- Google Workspace
Ease of Use
The dashboard is accessible and friendly for non-technical users.
PowerDMARC: Enterprise Features for Larger Security Teams
Advanced Authentication Tools
PowerDMARC provides:
- Hosted DKIM
- Hosted MTA-STS & TLS-RPT
- Hosted BIMI
- S/MIME encryption
The platform is particularly attractive for enterprise or government clients with deep compliance requirements.
User Permissions & MSP Portal
Its multi-tenant infrastructure helps MSPs manage domains at scale.
Integrations
Advanced API and SIEM integrations, including:
- Splunk
- Sentinel
- Elastic
Learning Curve
With many deep security layers, PowerDMARC can feel complex for smaller agencies needing speed over feature depth.
Pricing Overview: Which One Offers the Best Value?
DMARCReport: Transparent, Agency-Friendly Pricing
DMARCReport provides:
- Unlimited DMARC reporting
- Unlimited MTA-STS/TLS-RPT hosting
- Unlimited domains for agency plans
- White label portal included
- No per-domain overage fees
This predictable model is ideal for agencies reselling managed email authentication.
EasyDMARC: Good for Small Businesses
Plans are structured around:
- Domain count
- Reporting limits
- Advanced features (BIMI, forensic, security suite)
Agencies managing many domains may face incremental per-domain costs.
PowerDMARC: Premium Enterprise Pricing
PowerDMARC’s pricing is higher, reflecting:
- Hosted DKIM
- S/MIME encryption
- Enterprise integrations
- Advanced monitoring capabilities
Best suited for large orgs with stringent compliance requirements.
User Experience: Which Service Feels Best for Agencies?
DMARCReport: Clean, Clear & Built for Speed
- Lightweight dashboard
- Logical domain grouping
- Easy multi-domain switching
- Instant record status indicators
Ideal for agencies that need clarity when managing many clients simultaneously.
EasyDMARC: Visual & Beginner-Friendly
- Colorful dashboards
- Helpful guided steps
- Accessible for non-technical end users
PowerDMARC: Feature-Dense for Security Teams
- Very detailed reports
- Highly granular controls
- Best for technical specialists needing deep insight
Integrations & Compatibility
DMARCReport
- Full API access
- Flexible integration for in-house agency dashboards
- Automation-friendly
EasyDMARC
- Works well with Google Workspace & O365
- Good for SMB ecosystems
PowerDMARC
- SIEM integrations
- Complex enterprise stack compatibility
Why These Three Are the Top Email Authentication Platforms
DMARCReport
Best for digital agencies, MSPs, and resellers who want:
- White-label portals
- Bulk domain management
- Hosted MTA-STS with TLS-RPT
- Clean reporting clients understand
- Affordable multi-domain scaling
EasyDMARC
Best for small-to-mid businesses needing:
- Simple onboarding
- Fast DMARC policy guidance
- Easy-to-read dashboards
PowerDMARC
Best for enterprises needing:
- Advanced authentication methods
- Hosted DKIM & BIMI
- Security team-level granularity
Alternative Email Authentication Tools
If you’re exploring more options outside the big three, here are notable alternatives:
Valimail
Trusted enterprise provider with strong automation and strict compliance controls.
dmarcian
One of the longest-standing DMARC platforms with in-depth reporting and analysis.
Red Sift (OnDMARC)
Known for its polished UI and additional security tools like domain protection monitoring.
Postmark DMARC
Simple, lightweight DMARC monitoring for dev-first teams.
Final Verdict: EasyDMARC vs PowerDMARC vs DMARCReport—Which One Should Agencies Choose?
Each platform excels for different needs:
- DMARCReport is the ideal choice for digital agencies and MSPs seeking scalable DMARC & MTA-STS hosting with white-labeling, multi-domain management, and transparent pricing.
- EasyDMARC fits small businesses and teams new to DMARC who want clear visuals and guided onboarding.
- PowerDMARC is best for larger enterprises requiring layered authentication, hosted DKIM/BIMI, S/MIME, and compliance-grade reporting.
For agencies, the standout choice is DMARCReport—thanks to its focus on scalability, clarity, client communication, and fully hosted MTA-STS.
If you’re ready to protect all client domains and simplify your agency’s email security delivery, start by onboarding your first domain today.
